I can recommend Charge! on the following grounds, if they appeal to you:
1. It has a unique system for hitting the enemy, eliminating random chance as much as possible, giving players maximum choice and options. Damage is not random.
2. It is suitable for fleets against fleets because of the condensed rule system.
3. You can play it with whatever counters or miniatures you like. If you can differ... [click here for more]